Skip to content

Blog / VAT and Cross-Border Selling

When the VAT Flat Rate Scheme Is Wrong for Online Sellers (and When It Isn't)

Updated 2026-11-11 · 8 min read

Need help with your online selling taxes?

Key takeaways

  • Under FRS you can't reclaim the VAT on stock or other purchases (a single purchase of capital goods costing £2,000 or more, including VAT, is the exception). For a reseller that's usually the scheme's biggest cost.
  • The 16.5% limited cost business rate applies when relevant goods spend is below 2% of VAT-inclusive turnover or below £1,000 a year, and it is the highest rate in the scheme. Stock bought to resell counts towards that test when selling goods is your main business, so a stock seller normally pays its trade's rate instead (7.5% for retailing not listed elsewhere).
  • The VAT registration threshold is tested on gross sales, not the net payout your marketplace deposits in your bank.
  • Reverse-charged overseas platform and advertising fees sit outside the flat rate, in boxes 1 and 4 of your return, so they don't add to your flat rate turnover.
  • Model the actual numbers for your business before electing; for goods sellers the standard VAT scheme usually returns more.

Can you save VAT by joining the Flat Rate Scheme as an online seller? Usually not, and there's a simple line to check: at the 7.5% retail rate, FRS only comes out ahead while your stock and other costs that carry UK VAT stay under about 55% of your net sales. It's pitched as a simplification: pay one percentage of your gross sales and forget about reclaiming VAT on what you buy. That last part's the problem. If you buy stock, the VAT on it is money you'd normally get back, and on the flat rate you don't.

What you give up on the flat rate

Under the Flat Rate Scheme you pay a single percentage of your gross VAT-inclusive turnover to HMRC and keep the difference between that payment and the 20% VAT you charged customers. You don't reclaim the VAT on your purchases. The scheme was designed for businesses with few VAT-bearing costs, where there'd be little to reclaim under the standard scheme anyway.

For a goods seller the big cost is losing the VAT on stock. Buy £40,000 of stock a year from UK VAT-registered suppliers and that's £8,000 of VAT you'd reclaim on the standard scheme and lose on the flat rate. The rate you'd pay matters less. Stock you buy to resell counts towards the limited cost test when selling goods is your main business (VAT Notice 733, para 4.6), so a stock seller usually pays its trade's rate, 7.5% for retailing not listed elsewhere, rather than the 16.5% limited cost rate.

Want this checked against your specific situation?

Leave your details and a one-line summary. We'll come back to you, with no obligation.

We'll only use your details to respond to your enquiry. We don't pass them to any other firm. See our Privacy Policy.

How FRS works (one paragraph)

Once registered, you charge customers VAT at the standard 20% rate as normal. At the end of each VAT period you apply your flat rate percentage to your gross VAT-inclusive sales (turnover including the VAT you collected) and pay that amount to HMRC. You keep the spread between what you collected from customers and what you pay to HMRC. You do not deduct input VAT on purchases (except on a single purchase of capital goods costing £2,000 or more, including VAT). In your first year of VAT registration you take 1% off your rate. You can only join if you expect your taxable turnover for the next year, excluding VAT, to be £150,000 or less, and you can't join if you use the second-hand margin scheme (Notice 733, paras 3.1 and 3.6), so if you resell used goods on the margin scheme, the flat rate isn't open to you. The maths only works in your favour if your flat rate percentage is well below 20% and you'd have little input VAT to reclaim.

The real cost: you can't reclaim VAT on stock

This is the big cost for any reseller or importer. Under the standard VAT scheme every VATable purchase you make produces an input VAT credit you set against your output VAT. Under FRS there's no such credit. The VAT your supplier charged you is simply a cost.

Take that £40,000 of stock at 20% VAT. Under the standard scheme you get £8,000 back over the year. Under FRS it's lost, and so is the VAT on packaging, storage and any fees billed with UK VAT. In return you keep the gap between the 20% you charge and the flat rate: at 7.5% of VAT-inclusive sales you pay HMRC 9% of your net sales, so on £100,000 of net sales you keep £11,000. Whether that beats the VAT you'd have reclaimed is what the worked comparison below works out.

The effect is sharper for importers using postponed VAT accounting. Under the standard scheme a VAT-registered importer can account for import VAT on the return and recover it in the same period, so there's no net cash out. Under FRS that import VAT can't be recovered either. That's why FRS and importing are a particularly poor fit.

Where 16.5% comes in: the limited cost test

The limited cost business test works like this: if your spend on relevant goods, including VAT, is less than 2% of your VAT-inclusive turnover, or less than £1,000 a year (£250 a quarter), you're a limited cost business and must use 16.5%, the highest rate in the scheme. Relevant goods are goods used only for your business. They don't include vehicle costs and fuel, food and drink for you or your staff, capital items, promotional items and gifts, or any services. Stock you intend to resell counts when selling goods is your main business, and Notice 733 gives "stock for a shop" as an example, so a seller buying stock normally clears the test and uses its trade's rate.

The catch is that the test runs on each VAT period's own figures, so you can move between 16.5% and your sector rate from one return to the next (Notice 733, para 4.4). A quarter when you sell down stock you bought earlier and buy little new can drop you under 2%, and that whole quarter's turnover then goes at 16.5%.

Here's what the rate does to a year with £120,000 of VAT-inclusive sales (£100,000 net plus £20,000 VAT collected), before you count any VAT you'd have reclaimed on the standard scheme:

Item Trade rate, 7.5% Limited cost rate, 16.5%
VAT collected from customers (20% on £100,000 net) £20,000 £20,000
FRS payment to HMRC (rate × £120,000 gross) £9,000 £19,800
Amount retained under FRS £11,000 £200

At 16.5% you keep £200, so almost any VAT you'd reclaim on the standard scheme beats it. At 7.5% you keep £11,000, and that's the figure to set against the VAT on your stock and costs.

The marketplace-fee wrinkle

Overseas platform and advertising fees billed without UK VAT are reverse-charge services under Notice 741A. On the flat rate they're handled outside the scheme: you leave them out of your flat rate turnover and put the VAT in boxes 1 and 4 of your return, just as you would under normal accounting, so the two entries cancel out (Notice 733, para 6.4). The change announced at Budget 2026 for 1 April 2027 doesn't alter this, because it only ends the reverse charge for businesses that aren't VAT registered. The fees that cost you more on FRS are the ones billed with UK VAT: on the standard scheme you'd reclaim that VAT, and on the flat rate you can't. If your platform and ad fees carry UK VAT, count them with your stock when you work out what FRS would cost you.

See VAT on marketplace fees for how each kind of fee is treated. Choosing a scheme is part of how we help with VAT as an online seller.

When FRS might still make sense

FRS isn't wrong in every situation. It can come out ahead when there's little VAT on your costs: a high-margin seller, or one who buys mostly from suppliers who don't charge VAT, hasn't much input VAT to lose, and the admin saving of not reclaiming VAT on every purchase invoice is real. A seller of digital products is a different case. With next to no goods you'd be a limited cost business on 16.5%, keeping £200 per £100,000 of net sales, so the standard scheme wins once there's more than £200 of VAT to reclaim.

But for a marketplace seller buying, importing, storing and shipping physical goods with UK VAT on them, the lost input VAT adds up fast. The thinner your margin, the worse FRS looks.

If you sell through marketplaces, there's one more unknown. From October 2027 (announced at Budget 2026, not yet law), marketplaces are intended to account for the VAT on VAT-registered UK sellers' sales to consumers, and the government says it'll "take more time to consider how the Flat Rate Scheme will function" alongside that change (summary of consultation responses, October 2026, para 4.15). Don't join for the long term on the assumption that today's flat rate sums will still apply then.

Model it before you elect: a worked comparison

Rounded figures, for a stock seller who clears the limited cost test easily (its stock is 40% of VAT-inclusive turnover), so the flat rate is 7.5%. Your own answer depends on your margin, where you buy and which of your costs carry UK VAT.

Standard VAT FRS at 7.5%
Net sales (ex-VAT) £100,000 £100,000
Output VAT collected (20%) £20,000 £20,000
Input VAT on stock (20% on £40,000 stock) -£8,000 (recovered) Not recoverable
Input VAT on marketplace and fulfilment fees billed with UK VAT (£15,000 at 20%) -£3,000 (recovered) Not recoverable
Input VAT on other UK costs (£5,000 at 20%) -£1,000 (recovered) Not recoverable
Net VAT payable to HMRC £8,000 £9,000 (7.5% of £120,000 gross, with no input VAT recovered)
Annual VAT cost difference The standard scheme saves £1,000 a year. In your first year of registration FRS is £200 cheaper (6.5% of £120,000 is £7,800), and after that it costs more

The line to watch is 55%. At 7.5%, FRS costs you 9% of your net sales; the standard scheme costs 20% of your net sales less 20% of your costs that carry VAT. They meet when those costs reach 55% of net sales. Below that, FRS wins. Above it, the standard scheme does, and the gap grows with every pound of stock. Here the costs are £60,000, so the standard scheme is ahead; take out the £15,000 of fees and FRS would be £2,000 ahead instead. Zero-rated sales, such as goods you export, tilt it further against FRS, because the flat rate is charged on them too (Notice 733, para 6.2).

The seller take-home calculator works out your take-home on the standard scheme, with VAT, fees and stock in one place. It doesn't model the flat rate, so run the FRS side by hand with the sums above.

Where sellers go wrong with the flat rate

Electing FRS at VAT registration as a default. Accountants who handle both service and product businesses sometimes suggest FRS at registration because it's simpler to administer. For a service business that can be fine. For a goods seller it's a default that needs to be actively refused or modelled first. Always ask: how much VAT will I pay on stock and fees?

Missing the limited cost test. Stock you buy to resell counts towards the limited cost test when selling goods is your main business (VAT Notice 733 para 4.6), so a stock seller is normally on its trade's rate (7.5% for retailing not listed elsewhere). The 16.5% catches a seller whose goods spend in a period falls below 2% of turnover, or below £1,000 a year. HMRC applies the test to each VAT period, so a quarter when you buy little stock can still put that quarter on 16.5%.

Conflating turnover with bank deposits. The FRS is applied to gross VAT-inclusive turnover, which for a marketplace seller means gross sales, not the net amount deposited after platform fees. HMRC's VAT registration rules make clear that turnover is gross taxable sales; the same gross basis applies to the FRS calculation. Sellers who model FRS on their bank deposits systematically underestimate what they'll owe.

If you're approaching VAT registration for the first time and unsure which scheme fits your business, the ecommerce VAT compliance service covers scheme selection as part of the registration process. For sellers on Amazon in particular, see the Amazon sellers hub for the full VAT picture including import VAT, the £135 rule and fee treatment.

Frequently asked questions

Should an ecommerce seller use the Flat Rate Scheme?
Usually not. You can't reclaim the VAT on your stock, and for a goods seller that's normally worth more than the scheme saves, even at your trade's rate (7.5% for retailing not listed elsewhere) rather than 16.5%. At 7.5%, FRS only comes out ahead if your stock and other costs that carry UK VAT are under 55% of your net sales. Model both schemes on your own figures before deciding.
What is the limited cost business rate?
It's 16.5%, and it applies when your spend on relevant goods is less than 2% of your VAT-inclusive turnover, or less than £1,000 a year. See gov.uk/vat-flat-rate-scheme/how-much-you-pay for the full test.
Can I reclaim VAT on stock under the Flat Rate Scheme?
No. Under FRS you pay a flat percentage of your VAT-inclusive turnover and don't reclaim input VAT, stock included. The exceptions are a single purchase of capital goods costing £2,000 or more including VAT, and stock and assets you already hold when you register.
Am I a limited cost business?
You are if your spend on relevant goods (broadly, goods used only for your business, excluding food and drink for you or your staff, vehicle costs and capital items) is below 2% of your VAT-inclusive turnover, or below £1,000 a year. Stock you buy to resell counts as relevant goods if selling goods is your main business (VAT Notice 733 para 4.6), so if your stock purchases come to at least 2% of turnover and at least £1,000 a year you're not a limited cost business and you use your trade's rate (7.5% for retailing not listed elsewhere).
Does the Flat Rate Scheme apply to my Amazon or marketplace fees?
Not to reverse-charged ones. Fees billed from overseas without UK VAT are dealt with outside the scheme, in boxes 1 and 4 of your return, so the entries cancel out (VAT Notice 733 para 6.4). Fees billed with UK VAT are different: on FRS you can't reclaim that VAT, so it's a straight cost.
When is the Flat Rate Scheme worth it?
When there's little VAT on your costs to lose, which can be true of a high-margin seller. At the 7.5% retail rate it comes out ahead if your costs that carry UK VAT are under 55% of your net sales, and behind if they're over.

Need help with your online selling taxes?

Tell us about your store or marketplace accounts and we will come back within 24 hours.

Step 1 of 2 · About you

Related reading

Need help with your online selling taxes?

Tell us about your store or marketplace accounts and we will come back within 24 hours.

Step 1 of 2 · About you