Skip to content

Help responding to an HMRC letter about your online selling income.

If HMRC has written to you about your eBay, Vinted, Etsy or Amazon sales, it has probably already seen what the platform reported about you. Since 1 January 2024, digital platforms have had to report seller income to HMRC for each calendar year by 31 January, and give you a copy of the same report by that date. So find your copy first, check it against your tax returns for the years the letter mentions, and reply by any date it gives. You can do that yourself, and if your returns already include the income, your reply can say just that. If they don't, or you never registered for Self Assessment, we'll work out what you actually owe, put it right with HMRC and keep any penalty as low as the facts allow. What platforms report, and when, is in our guide to the platform reporting rules.

From Jan 2024
Platform reporting rules took effect; platforms report seller data to HMRC covering the 2024 period, with annual reports due each 31 January and a copy to each seller by the same date
Not a tax threshold
The platform-reporting exclusion (fewer than 30 sales of goods and €2,000, about £1,700, or less) determines whether the platform reports you, not whether you owe tax
5 October
Self Assessment registration deadline following the end of the tax year in which taxable selling income first arose

The letter in your hand

Work out which of these you've got before you reply. Each one asks something different of you.

The letter in your hand
What you've gotWho it's fromWhat it meansYour first step
A letter or email asking you to check your returns against what HMRC knows about your online sales (a nudge letter)HMRC, sent to many sellers at onceHMRC calls these 'One to Many' letters. On its own one isn't a compliance check, and it doesn't say you owe taxCompare the platform's report with your returns. If they're right, say so; if not, correct them
A letter opening a compliance check, pointing you to factsheet CC/FS1aAn HMRC officerHMRC is checking your tax position and can ask you for information and documentsNote the officer's deadline, gather your platform reports and records, and get advice before you send anything
Your yearly digital sales reportThe platformA copy of what the platform sent HMRC about you for the calendar year, due by 31 JanuarySplit the figures into tax years (6 April to 5 April) and check them against your records and returns
An email saying your digital sales report has been correctedThe platformThe platform has changed the figures it reports about you. HMRC can't correct a platform's report itselfCheck the corrected report against your own sales records. If it changes a return you've filed, amend that return
Not sure a letter or email is really from HMRC? GOV.UK keeps a list of genuine HMRC contact you can check it against. Source: GOV.UK Submit your digital platform report.

The problem

The challenges clients face.

Understanding what the HMRC letter is actually saying

HMRC's platform-reporting letters come in several forms. Some are what HMRC calls 'One to Many' letters, better known as nudge letters: the same letter goes to many sellers asking them to check their returns, and on its own it isn't a compliance check. Others ask you to explain a difference between your return and the platform's figures. When HMRC does open a formal compliance check, it'll point you to factsheet CC/FS1a. The right response depends on which one you've received, and a nudge letter may be settled by filing or amending a return. HMRC plans what it'll do when people don't respond, so ignoring a letter, or replying wrongly, can escalate the matter. Platform reporting has applied from 1 January 2024, with the first reports covering 2024 submitted in January 2025.

Establishing whether your selling is trading income

Not all online selling is taxable trading income. Occasional sales of personal possessions are generally not trading. Regular buying and reselling, or volume casual selling, typically is. The boundary is a badges-of-trade question (profit-seeking motive, frequency of transactions, nature of the asset, how goods were acquired), not a sales-count question. The platform-reporting exclusion (fewer than 30 sales of goods and €2,000, about £1,700, or less in the period) determines whether the platform reports you, not whether you owe tax. HMRC's letter may require you to confirm your trading status.

Calculating unreported income for prior years

If you've had trading income from selling online that never went on a return, you can put it right before HMRC asks. If you're in Self Assessment, you amend the return; for earlier years, or if you never registered, HMRC's route is its digital disclosure service, where you tell HMRC you're disclosing and then have 90 days to send the disclosure and the payment. How far back you go depends on why it was missed: up to 4 years if you took reasonable care, 6 if you were careless, and 20 if it was deliberate or you didn't register when you should have, unless you had a reasonable excuse. Penalties are a percentage of the unpaid tax, set by Finance Act 2007 Schedule 24 for wrong returns and Finance Act 2008 Schedule 41 for not registering, and the table further down shows how far disclosure brings them down. Late payment interest runs from the date the tax was due, at 7.75% a year from 9 January 2026. The £1,000 trading allowance can reduce the taxable amount where gross trading income is above the allowance, or mean no tax where income is £1,000 or below. Don't count on the £3,000 allowance announced at Budget 2026 for the years a letter asks about: it isn't due until 6 April 2027 and isn't law yet. And from 1 April 2028 (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in Finance Bill 2026-27), you'll have a general duty to correct inaccurate returns, and HMRC a new power to issue Customer Correction Notices asking you to correct a return or explain why it's right.

Records to support your response

Start with the platform's own copy of what it reported. It covers a calendar year and shows what you were paid after fees, so before you compare it with a return you'll need to add the fees back and re-cut it into tax years (6 April to 5 April). Then pull your order history, what you paid for stock, the platform's fees, and anything that shows what the items were: receipts for things you bought for yourself are what separate a clear-out from a trade. We put all of that into a reply HMRC can follow.

The work

How we help.

01

Assess your actual tax position before responding

We go through your platform sales history, tell you whether what you've been doing counts as trading, work out the right income and expenses, and find any gap between what HMRC holds and what you've reported.
02

Prepare and submit your response or voluntary disclosure

We'll draft your reply to the HMRC letter, amend your Self Assessment return where it's needed, or make a disclosure for earlier years through HMRC's digital disclosure service, with the penalty worked out on what actually happened.
03

Set up ongoing tax compliance for your selling

Once the letter's dealt with, we'll register you for Self Assessment if you need it and keep your books and returns going, so your selling is reported properly from here on. The self-assessment registration deadline is 5 October following the end of the tax year in which the income arose; missing it can trigger a failure-to-notify penalty unless you had a reasonable excuse. There's more on how we work with eBay, Etsy and Vinted sellers.

How far disclosure brings a penalty down

A penalty for a wrong return is a percentage of the tax that went unpaid. Why it happened sets the range; when and how fully you tell HMRC sets where you land in it.

How far disclosure brings a penalty down
Why the return was wrongMaximumLowest if you tell HMRC firstLowest once HMRC has prompted you
Careless30%0%15%
Deliberate70%20%35%
Deliberate and concealed100%30%50%
Example: £2,000 of tax missed through carelessness could carry no penalty if you disclose before HMRC asks, but at least £300 once it has. Penalties for not registering when you should have share these maximums with different lowest rates, and there's none for a non-deliberate failure if you had a reasonable excuse. Source: Finance Act 2007 Schedule 24.

Example figures displayed. They show how the rules work, not your own position. Your outcome depends on your circumstances.

Common questions

I received a letter from HMRC about my eBay or Vinted sales. Do I owe tax?
Not necessarily, but you need to check. HMRC's letter comes from platform data and doesn't mean HMRC has decided you owe tax. It's asking you to confirm your Self Assessment returns include your online selling income. If you've only been selling your own possessions now and then, that's generally not taxable. If it's a trading activity, income above the trading allowance and applicable tax thresholds is taxable.
What is the platform-reporting exclusion and does it mean I am tax-free?
The platform-reporting exclusion (fewer than 30 sales of goods and €2,000, about £1,700, or less in the reporting period) determines whether the platform reports your data to HMRC, not whether you owe tax. Sellers below the exclusion threshold who have taxable trading income still owe that tax. The exclusion is a data-reporting rule, not a tax exemption.
Should I respond to an HMRC nudge letter?
Yes. Ignoring HMRC nudge letters doesn't make them go away: HMRC plans its follow-up for people who don't respond, and that can include a compliance check. If your returns are correct, the response is a confirmation. If there are gaps, correcting them yourself cuts the penalty, and it cuts it further if the disclosure is unprompted: for a careless error the minimum is 0% unprompted against 15% prompted (Finance Act 2007 Schedule 24), and the same test applies to penalties for not registering. Whether yours counts as unprompted is a test of the facts, not a label you choose: it's unprompted only if you'd no reason to believe HMRC had discovered the problem or was about to. So once HMRC has written to you about your platform income, don't assume you'll get the unprompted rate.

Speak to an ecommerce tax specialist.

Tell us about your situation and we will reply within 24 hours.

Step 1 of 2 · About you