Blog / Business Structure and Tax
Sole Trader or Limited Company for Online Sellers? The 2026/27 Numbers That Decide It
Updated 2026-11-11 · 10 min read
Need help with your online selling taxes?Key takeaways
- The decision hinges on profit level, extraction need, and stock reinvestment, not on turnover alone.
- Corporation tax runs at 19% on profits up to £50,000 and 25% above £250,000, with marginal relief between those bands.
- Dividend rates from 6 April 2026 are 10.75% (basic), 35.75% (higher) and 39.35% (additional) above a £500 annual allowance, higher than the old 8.75%/33.75% figures you'll still find in older guides.
- At the 2026/27 rates, a seller who draws out all their profit pays more tax through a company than as a sole trader at every profit above £5,000 (on a £5,000 salary, the rest as dividends and no other income); the company advantage comes from profit you retain and reinvest.
- Profit you leave in a company pays corporation tax now, and dividend tax waits until you draw it out. That edge is smaller for profit that goes into stock: a sole trader on the cash basis, the default, deducts stock when it's paid for, while a company only deducts it once it's sold.
- Run your own numbers through the sole-trader-vs-ltd-sellers calculator before deciding; a single worked example cannot represent your position.
Compare income tax rates with corporation tax rates and you've got half the answer. That comparison's right as far as it goes, but it misses the two factors that actually move the decision for sellers: how much cash you need to extract each year, and how much you reinvest into stock. Those two can shift the right structure entirely, even at the same headline profit.
So start with the 2026/27 rates, the reinvestment factor and one worked example at £70,000 of profit, then put your actual figures into the sole-trader-vs-ltd-sellers calculator, because a single example can't represent your position.
The short answer: the decision rule
Stay a sole trader if you need to draw out nearly everything you make. When every pound comes out each year, our calculator has the sole trader ahead at every profit above £5,000: by £1,698 at £40,000, £1,622 at £70,000 and £4,854 at £100,000. That's on its assumptions (a £5,000 salary, the rest as dividends, no other income), and it's before you've paid for a company's accounts and filings. A company starts to earn its place when you can leave profit in it to fund growth, because that profit pays corporation tax now and dividend tax only when you take it out. The reinvestment factor (below) adjusts this in one direction or the other depending on how stock-heavy your business is.
Neither structure is obviously correct for every seller. The right answer depends on your numbers.
What actually differs between the two structures
First, does a sole trader count as a private seller? No. If you buy or make things to sell at a profit, you're trading, and trading on your own account is what being a sole trader means, whether or not you've told HMRC yet. Clearing out your own belongings is different, and HMRC decides which side you're on from the overall picture of its badges of trade, not from a sales count. Our trading allowance guide goes through those tests. Once you're trading, the choice is whether to do it as a sole trader or through a company.
| Factor | Sole trader | Limited company |
|---|---|---|
| Tax on profit | Income tax (20%/40%/45%) plus Class 4 NIC (6%/2%) on self-employment profit | Corporation tax at 19% (up to £50,000) or 25% (above £250,000), marginal relief between |
| Extraction tax | None (profit is already yours) | Dividend tax (or salary) on amounts drawn out; dividends taxed at 10.75%/35.75%/39.35% above £500 allowance (2026/27) |
| NIC on profit | Class 4 NIC at 6% on profit £12,570 to £50,270; 2% above | No NIC on company profit; employer NIC applies on salary drawn from the company |
| Retained profit | Taxed in full in the year earned | Taxed at corporation tax rates; dividend tax deferred until extraction |
| Limited liability | Personal assets at risk from business debts | Company debts separate from personal assets (with caveats on personal guarantees) |
| Compliance overhead | Self Assessment return; simpler bookkeeping | Statutory accounts, corporation tax return (CT600), Companies House filings, likely a payroll run |
| Credibility and banking | Simpler; some suppliers and platforms treat sole traders differently | Separate legal entity; some marketplace and supplier relationships easier |
The 2026/27 tax maths
Two sets of rates drive the comparison.
As a sole trader
Your trading profit sits on top of any other income and is taxed at income tax rates: 20% basic rate, 40% higher rate, 45% additional rate (thresholds frozen through 2027/28). On top of income tax, Class 4 NIC runs at 6% on profit between £12,570 and £50,270, and 2% above £50,270. A sole trader making £60,000 of self-employment profit faces 40% income tax on the higher-rate slice plus 2% Class 4 NIC above the upper threshold, a combined marginal rate of 42% on that portion.
As a limited company (salary plus dividends)
The company pays corporation tax at 19% on profits up to £50,000 (small profits rate) or 25% on profits above £250,000, with marginal relief between, so a new seller company making £50,000 or less pays 19%. The director-shareholder then draws a low salary (up to the NIC secondary threshold of £5,000 per year to avoid employer NIC) and takes remaining extraction as dividends. Pay more than £5,000 and the company owes employer NIC at 15% on the excess, and it can't claim the Employment Allowance to cover it when you're its only director and the only employee paid above that level. A £5,000 salary is below the £6,708 lower earnings limit for 2026/27, though, so on its own it won't give you a National Insurance qualifying year towards your State Pension.
Dividend tax from 6 April 2026 applies at 10.75% (basic rate), 35.75% (higher rate), 39.35% (additional rate) on dividends above the £500 annual allowance, under Finance Act 2026 s.4. These rates are higher than the 8.75%/33.75% figures that still appear in guides written before the 2026 Act. If you're modelling the comparison using the old rates, your calculation is wrong.
Stay inside the basic-rate band and each pound of company profit you draw out pays 19% corporation tax, then 10.75% dividend tax on the 81p that's left: about 27.7p in all, against 26p of income tax and Class 4 for a sole trader in the same band. Between £50,000 and £250,000 of company profit, marginal relief takes the corporation tax on each extra pound to 26.5%. So the old assumption that extraction through a company always beats sole-trader tax doesn't hold any more, and the worked example below shows it at £70,000.
The seller wrinkle: cash reinvested into stock
Here's the factor a generic sole-trader-vs-Ltd comparison leaves out, and your accounting basis decides how it cuts. On traditional accounting, profit is taxed whether or not it's sitting in a warehouse as stock: buy £20,000 of Christmas stock in October, still have it at your year end, and you owe tax on that £20,000 of profit even though the cash has already left your bank account. A company is always on traditional accounting. A sole trader on the cash basis, the default since 2024/25, deducts stock when it's paid for, so that £20,000 comes off this year's profit and isn't taxed until the stock sells (HMRC's cash basis manual).
A limited company's retained profit is taxed at corporation tax rates (19% on profits up to £50,000, with marginal relief up to £250,000), not income tax rates. If you leave cash inside the company to fund the next stock buy, you defer the higher dividend tax until you actually need the money personally. Against a sole trader on traditional accounting, that's a meaningful cash-flow benefit for a fast-growing seller putting most of its profit back into stock. Against one on the cash basis it mostly goes, because the sole trader's new stock is already deducted; the company's edge is then on profit it keeps as cash.
The flip side: if you need to extract nearly all your profit to cover personal costs, the deferral benefit disappears and you're left comparing corporation tax plus dividend tax against income tax. At 2026/27 dividend rates, a seller who extracts everything comes out behind through a company, before its extra running costs are even counted.
The reinvestment factor therefore pushes the balance toward a limited company for sellers who can leave money in the business, and away from it for sellers who need to draw nearly all of their profit personally.
Worked example at a typical seller profit level
The figures below are illustrative at a profit of £70,000, with the director-shareholder having no other income and extracting the full amount each year. Numbers are rounded for clarity. Run the calculator for your exact position.
| Sole trader | Limited company (full extraction) | |
|---|---|---|
| Profit before owner pay | £70,000 | £70,000 (salary £5,000 deducted, taxable profit £65,000) |
| Corporation tax (25% main rate less marginal relief on £65,000) | n/a | approx £13,500 |
| Available for extraction | £70,000 (pre personal tax) | Salary £5,000 + dividends approx £51,500 |
| Income tax | approx £15,400 | Dividend tax approx £6,200 (salary sits within the personal allowance) |
| Class 4 NIC on profit | approx £2,650 | none (salary below the NIC thresholds) |
| Total tax | approx £18,100 | approx £19,700 |
| Difference at FULL extraction | the company route costs approx £1,600 MORE per year, before compliance costs | |
At £70,000 of profit with full extraction, the limited company is now slightly worse off under the 2026/27 rates, before the extra accountancy, payroll and Companies House costs are even counted. The calculator gives the unrounded figures: £18,089 of tax as a sole trader against £19,710 through the company, a gap of £1,622. The FA 2026 dividend rates widened it. At the old 8.75% and 33.75% rates the dividend tax here would've been £5,366, so the company would still have cost £752 more; the new rates add another £869.
The picture changes when profit stays in the company. Say the same seller draws £40,000 (the £5,000 salary plus £35,000 of dividends) and leaves the rest in to fund stock. Dividend tax falls to £2,895, so this year's total bill is £16,370 against the sole trader's £18,089, about £1,700 less. The £16,525 left in the company after corporation tax still carries dividend tax when you take it out later, so part of that gap is tax put off rather than saved. And £18,089 is a sole trader taxed on all £70,000. On the cash basis, a sole trader who spends the same £16,525 on new stock deducts it, which cuts the bill to about £11,150 and keeps the sole trader ahead. So retention earns its keep for growth-mode sellers against traditional accounting, or on profit you'd keep as cash rather than stock.
Change the salary and the numbers move too. Pay yourself £12,570 instead of £5,000 and the company owes employer NIC of £1,136 on the slice above £5,000, with no Employment Allowance to cover it if you're the only director and the only employee paid above that level. On full extraction that narrows the gap, and between roughly £60,000 and £61,000 of profit the two routes come within about £30 of each other; either side of that band the sole trader pulls ahead again. The higher salary does give you a National Insurance qualifying year, which £5,000 doesn't.
These are illustrative figures only. Your salary level, pension contributions, other income, stock cycle timing, and compliance costs all shift the outcome. Use the calculator with your numbers.
Run your own numbers
The calculator takes your profit after platform fees and stock costs and runs both routes side by side at 2026/27 rates, on the assumption that you draw everything out. It accounts for the corporation tax bands and marginal relief, the £500 dividend allowance, and the FA 2026 dividend rates. It doesn't model profit you leave in the company, so use the retained-profit example above for that side of the decision.
Open the sole trader vs limited company calculator for online sellers
If you want to model your true take-home after marketplace fees and cost of goods, the seller take-home calculator works alongside this one.
Calculator
Sole Trader vs Ltd Company (Sellers)
For marketplace and ecommerce sellers, the structure decision is not the same as for a service business. A company always uses traditional accounting, so stock it hasn't sold yet isn't a cost and its taxable profit can run ahead of its cash, while a sole trader on the cash basis (the default since 2024/25) deducts stock when it's paid for. Platform fees change the income picture before the tax comparison even starts. This calculator runs the sole-trader and limited-company take-home side by side at your profit level, after you have already deducted platform fees, cost of goods and other business costs. It uses 2026/27 rates for income tax, Class 4 NIC, corporation tax and dividend rates under Finance Act 2026.
Net profit after deducting platform fees (referral, fulfilment), cost of goods sold and all other allowable costs. Enter the figure before any personal income tax or NIC. If you use the seller take-home calculator to model your costs, the net profit figure it shows is the one to enter here.
Your result
Your answer's ready. Press below to see it.
Non-tax factors for sellers
The tax maths is the main driver, but three non-tax factors matter for ecommerce businesses specifically.
Limited liability on stock and supplier debt
A sole trader carries unlimited personal liability for business debts. For a seller running on supplier credit, buying forward stock, or using inventory financing, a bad trading year can expose personal assets. A limited company ring-fences company debts from your personal finances, though lenders frequently require a personal guarantee from directors of small companies, which reduces (but does not eliminate) that protection.
Marketplace and platform account rules
Amazon, eBay and similar platforms treat a limited company as a separate legal entity from the director personally. This can be relevant for account reinstatement, brand registry, and in some cases for aggregator or brokers-led exit discussions where a share sale (of the company) is more attractive than an asset sale. Check the platform's seller agreement for your specific situation. If a sale's on the cards, Business Asset Disposal Relief taxes qualifying gains at 18% from 6 April 2026, whether you sell your company's shares or, as a sole trader, the business itself. Its £1 million lifetime limit is due to fall to £500,000 for sales on or after 6 April 2027 (announced at Budget 2026, not yet law).
Credibility with suppliers and trade accounts
Some wholesale suppliers and trade-account providers are more willing to extend credit terms to a limited company than to a sole trader, because the company exists as a searchable, registered entity with publicly filed accounts. This is a practical benefit that grows as your business scales.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. We'll come back to you, with no obligation.
Generic incorporation mechanics: how to actually set up a limited company
Setting up the company is the same job for any business: Companies House registration, share structure, articles of association, and moving your trade across from sole trader to limited company. Companies House sets out the registration process at gov.uk, and we can talk you through it on the first call. You can read how we work with online sellers first.
Common failure modes
Incorporating too early
One mistake is incorporating at a profit level where there's no tax to save. At £25,000 of profit drawn in full, the calculator has the sole trader £1,442 ahead before you've paid anything for the company's accounts and filings. Incorporation makes sense when the numbers stack up, not as a reflexive "professional" move.
Modelling at the old dividend rates
Older sole-trader-versus-limited-company comparisons still use the pre-FA2026 dividend rates of 8.75% and 33.75%. Those rates no longer apply from 6 April 2026. The correct 2026/27 rates are 10.75% (basic) and 35.75% (higher) under Finance Act 2026 s.4. If your adviser's model or any online calculator still uses the old rates, the saving it shows is overstated.
Ignoring the stock reinvestment factor
A comparison that treats all profit as extracted understates the limited company advantage for growth-mode sellers. Conversely, a comparison that assumes all profit is retained overstates it for sellers who need the cash personally. Model the extraction you actually plan to make, not the theoretical optimum.
For the right numbers for your business, use the sole trader vs limited company calculator, or talk to us about your ecommerce structure through our ecommerce tax services. Selling on Amazon or running a Shopify store? Our pages for Amazon sellers and Shopify sellers cover what changes on each platform.
Frequently asked questions
Should my Amazon or eBay business be a limited company?
What are the 2026/27 dividend tax rates?
At what profit does incorporating a seller business pay off?
Does reinvesting into stock change the sole-trader-vs-Ltd answer?
Is a limited company better for limiting liability as a seller?
Do I pay corporation tax on all my company profit?
Need help with your online selling taxes?
Tell us about your store or marketplace accounts and we will come back within 24 hours.
Related reading
Need help with your online selling taxes?
Tell us about your store or marketplace accounts and we will come back within 24 hours.