Blog / Bookkeeping and Inventory
Cash Basis or Accruals for a Stock Business? What Online Sellers Should Choose
Updated 2026-11-11 · 7 min read
Need help with your online selling taxes?Key takeaways
- Cash basis is the standard way for sole traders and partnerships without corporate partners; limited companies and LLPs can't use it. To use accruals instead, you say on your Self Assessment return that you used traditional accounting.
- Under cash basis, a large stock purchase shows as an immediate cost even if the goods have not yet sold, distorting your profit picture.
- Accruals matches cost of goods to the sales they relate to, giving you a true picture of margin on each batch.
- Closing stock is valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value under accruals.
- Changing basis needs a one-off adjustment. Leave the cash basis and the paid-for stock you're holding comes back into profit, spread over six years unless you choose to speed it up.
- MTD for Income Tax (from April 2026) does not mandate accruals, but it does make a clean bookkeeping basis more important.
When you set up as a sole trader selling online, HMRC's cash basis applies by default. For a freelancer or service provider that's usually fine. If you buy stock to resell, it's usually the wrong fit, and the reason is the stock.
Which basis are you on?
Since 2024/25, cash basis is the standard way for sole traders and partnerships without corporate partners to work out their profit. Limited companies and LLPs can't use it, so a company is always on accruals. If you're a sole trader and want accruals (gov.uk calls it traditional accounting), you don't fill in a separate form: you say on your Self Assessment return that you used it. Source: HMRC cash basis guidance.
Our view for a stock-based ecommerce seller: accruals with proper inventory tracking usually gives better decision data and smoother taxable profits. Gov.uk says much the same thing, naming a business that "has high levels of stock" as one that might choose traditional accounting. Either way, choose the basis on purpose. Don't just inherit it.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. We'll come back to you, with no obligation.
What the two bases actually mean
The difference is when income and costs land in your accounts, not how much you'll owe over a lifetime of trading.
- Cash basis: income is recognised when money arrives; costs are recognised when money leaves. Stock you buy to resell is a cost the day you pay for it, and there's no closing-stock figure at the year end. It's simple to record, but the timing of cash movements drives what your accounts show.
- Accruals basis: income is recognised when it's earned (when you sell the goods) and costs when they're incurred (when you consume or sell the stock). Stock you haven't sold yet sits on a closing-stock balance, not in your costs.
If you never hold inventory overnight, there's barely any difference between the two. Buy a pallet of stock, hold it for weeks or months and sell it in batches, and the difference can be dramatic.
Why it matters for a stock business
Under accruals, cost of goods sold (COGS) is matched to the sales it relates to. Goods you've bought but not yet sold sit as a closing-stock asset, valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value, per HMRC BIM33115. So your taxable profit reflects your trading performance in the period.
Under cash basis, every pound you spend on stock is a cost in the period you pay for it, whether or not any of it has sold. That drags costs into periods with no matching sales, then inflates profit later, when the goods sell and there's no purchase cost against them.
| Feature | Cash basis | Accruals basis |
|---|---|---|
| Who can use it | Sole traders; partnerships without corporate partners | Anyone; limited companies and LLPs must use it |
| Stock treatment | Cost recognised when paid, regardless of sales | Cost matched to sales; unsold stock on balance sheet |
| Taxable-profit smoothness | Whipsaws with stock-purchase timing | Tracks trading performance period by period |
| Decision data | Hard to read true margin on a product line | COGS per sale visible; margin analysis reliable |
| Complexity | Simpler record-keeping in year | Requires year-end stock count and valuation |
| How you choose it | Nothing to do: it's the standard for sole traders and eligible partnerships | You say on your Self Assessment return that you used traditional accounting |
What cash basis distorts for a seller: a worked example
Say you spend £8,000 on a wholesale stock order in March. By 5 April (the tax year end) you've sold goods that cost £3,000 for £5,400. The other £5,000 of stock, at cost, is sitting in your storage.
Cash basis result: your accounts show the full £8,000 as a cost in the year, against £5,400 of sales. That's a £2,600 loss on this batch, and the £5,000 of goods you still own appear nowhere. Your profit looks £5,000 worse than your actual trading performance.
Accruals result: your accounts show £3,000 of COGS against the £5,400 of sales, a £2,400 profit, plus a £5,000 closing-stock asset. That stock carries forward to next year as a cost that'll reduce profit when the goods sell.
Now say you sell the rest next year for £9,000. Cash basis shows £9,000 of profit on it, with no cost at all, because you deducted the stock last year. Accruals shows £4,000 (£9,000 less the £5,000 brought forward). Over the two years you're taxed on £6,400 either way. What changes is which year carries it, and whether your accounts tell you anything useful about margin along the way.
Scale that across a business that keeps buying and holding, and the distortion compounds. While you're building stock, cash basis makes you look less profitable than you are. When you run stock down without buying more, it makes you look more profitable.
The MTD for Income Tax context
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax requires sole-trader sellers to keep digital records and send quarterly updates once their self-employment and property income before expenses passes the threshold on the previous year's return: over £50,000 on the 2024/25 return means MTD from 6 April 2026, over £30,000 on the 2025/26 return from 6 April 2027, and over £20,000 on the 2026/27 return from 6 April 2028. Source: HMRC MTD-IT eligibility guidance.
MTD doesn't mandate accruals, and you can stay on cash basis and comply. Gov.uk also says you don't need to make accounting adjustments before a quarterly update, so on accruals your stock count is still a year-end job. What MTD does is raise the cost of sloppy bookkeeping. Your running totals go to HMRC four times a year, so a distorted profit picture shows up every quarter instead of once in January.
For how the quarterly updates work and what records you'll need, see our MTD ITSA guide for online sellers.
Switching from cash basis to accruals
There's no separate election to send HMRC. You switch by preparing accruals accounts and saying on your Self Assessment return that you used traditional accounting. It won't happen on its own as you grow. The natural trigger is a year where your stock is big enough for the distortion to matter, or where you want reliable margin data for buying decisions.
The switch needs a transitional adjustment, because otherwise some income and costs would be taxed or deducted twice, or not at all. On leaving the cash basis, HMRC's rule (BIM72071) adds together what customers owed you and what you paid for the stock you're still holding, then takes off what you owed suppliers and any income received in advance for work not yet done. A positive answer is adjustment income, taxed a sixth a year over six years unless you choose to speed it up. So with £5,000 of paid-for stock on hand and nothing else outstanding, you'd have £5,000 of adjustment income, about £833 a year for six years.
It works the other way too. If you move onto the cash basis from accruals, last year's closing stock is added to your purchases in the first cash basis year, so you still get relief for it (BIM72065). This isn't something to improvise. A clean year-end is the right moment, and planning the transition with a bookkeeper or accountant before the new tax year starts saves unwinding errors later.
Our settlement and payout reconciliation service is designed to support exactly this kind of structured bookkeeping clean-up, including basis-switch transitions for growing seller businesses.
When cash basis can still fit
Cash basis isn't wrong for every seller. If you hold very little stock (you're essentially a dropshipper with nothing in hand, you sell digital products, or your stock is small and turns quickly), the distortion is minor and cash basis's simplicity may be the right trade-off.
Where cash basis tends to hold up:
- Very low stock value at any given time (turnover is rapid, stock is never a material balance)
- Side-hustle scale where total receipts are modest and bookkeeping overhead is a real constraint
- Service-heavy hybrid businesses where the trading activity is mostly labour or digital delivery
If you sell on Amazon, eBay, Etsy or Shopify and regularly carry stock worth more than a few hundred pounds, the case for cash basis rests on two things: less bookkeeping in the year, and tax put off while your stock is growing, because stock is deducted when you pay for it. The first shrinks once you've got a proper inventory system in place; the second reverses when you run stock down. See the Amazon sellers hub and marketplace sellers hub for how we approach bookkeeping for different seller profiles.
Where the basis goes wrong as you grow
Two things tend to go wrong as a seller grows:
Drifting on cash basis while scaling stock. You start out with £500 of stock, cash basis works fine, and nobody revisits it as the business grows. By the time stock is £20,000 or more, the cash-basis profit picture is badly distorted. The tax may still come out right over a lifetime of trading, because the costs flow through either way, but the management information isn't reliable, and the year-end swings in taxable profit make planning hard.
Switching without transitional adjustments. Move to accruals mid-trade without pinning down the stock you've paid for, what customers owe you and what you owe suppliers at the switch date, and you'll have a gap in your books. Stock you already deducted on the cash basis comes back as adjustment income rather than being deducted twice, and sales already counted under one basis mustn't be counted again under the other. The transitional year is the one to get right.
Both are preventable with a deliberate decision at the right moment, rather than drift. If you're not sure which basis your current accounts use, or whether a switch makes sense, our bookkeeping and reconciliation service can review your position.
Frequently asked questions
Should an online seller use cash basis or accruals?
What is the difference between cash basis and accruals?
Is cash basis the default for sole traders?
Why is accruals better for a stock business?
Does MTD for Income Tax force accruals accounting?
Can I switch from cash basis to accruals?
Need help with your online selling taxes?
Tell us about your store or marketplace accounts and we will come back within 24 hours.
Related reading
Need help with your online selling taxes?
Tell us about your store or marketplace accounts and we will come back within 24 hours.